sábado, 3 de marzo de 2012

TWO AND TWO MAKE FIVE

"Two and two make five" is one of the most important sentences of the third part, it appears in the chapter twelve. It shows us how Winston had to accept that two plus two make five knowing that this is completely imposible.
Everything starts after the state found Winston with Julia, so they, to punish him, took him to a machine that gives electric shocks and the man who is controlling the machine is talking with Winston and showing him his hand with four fingers raised while asking Winston how many fingers are there. Winston is completely sure that there are just four fingers but when he says four, the man switch on the machine producing a terrible pain to Winston. However, Winston still thinks that there are just four fingers until he had a conversation with the man and for some seconds, Winston saw five fingers.
This part of the book shows us how people can change our thoughts, our mind if they have the power. Winston at the beggining was sure that two plus two make four but after the pain he felt when they used the machine, the man could convince him that two plus two make five. O'Brien tortures Winston with electroshock to show him the perception could be manipulated, to make Winston see what the Party demands one should see. So, it shows that once they have tried to change your mind and they do it, you are dead.

I suppose we should say goodbye

We can see that sentence in the last chapter of the second part of the book 1984, that shows us how difficult was to live there doing whatever they want without breaking rules or being discovered.

In that part Julia and Winston are in the room that they rent where was suppose that no telescreen where in there. They are lying on the bed together until suddenly, they hear a voice that repeats everything they say and it says to them that they had to go to the middle of the room, so they can see them through the telescreen and not to move. They knew that they were discovered so, they thought that they should say goodbye because they will never see each other again.
With that sentence, I realise how difficult was to live there because they had to do what the government told to them because if not they could be punished, but they didn't surrender and they fight for their love. I understood, while reading that part, that you cannot trust anybody like Winston trust in the man who rent him the room and tells him that there are no telescreens in there but as the man lie, they are discovered. One thing that call my attention is that when they knew that they had been discovered they knew that they should say goodbye because they were doing something that was forbbiden. I can't stay in their place so I don't know how I would feel about it but maybe, if I knew that they can discover me and punish me I wouldn't do anything.